The point I have made is regarding adult football not just senior. In fact I specifically mention adult football a number of times.
You mentioned A champo so I responded with a statement saying you don't always need fantastic underage success, you only need a couple of lads ready to step straight to senior. As you have said, they haven't won an A champo in donkeys but they have been generally successful at all levels of adult football in recent years. I can't see that football success continuing, due to what looks like a focus on hurling from the club.
The current issue in Vincent's is there are maybe 8/9 lads going to adult football, not just that there are none going straight to senior.